Cracked, uneven, or worn concrete is a common issue for homeowners — especially in Texas, where clay soil movement, weather changes, and age all take a toll. While small cracks or minor issues can often be repaired, there comes a point where repairing concrete becomes a temporary fix rather than a long-term solution.

At Vicente Outdoor Living, we help homeowners determine whether their concrete needs repair or a complete replacement. If you're unsure what your concrete really needs, here’s how to make the right call.

1. When Cracks Keep Coming Back (Even After Repairs)

Small cracks happen — they’re normal. But if cracks continue reopening or spreading after multiple repairs, it’s usually a sign of deeper issues.

Recurring cracks often indicate:

  • soil movement
  • poor foundation beneath the slab
  • root growth
  • improper installation
  • water erosion

Repairing cracks over and over may only hide the symptom, not fix the problem.

2. When the Concrete Is Sunken or Uneven

If your concrete has shifted noticeably, replacement is usually the safest option.

Uneven concrete is caused by:

  • soil settling
  • erosion
  • drainage issues
  • tree roots
  • poor compaction during installation

Sunken slabs can lead to trip hazards, pooling water, and long-term structural damage.

3. When the Surface Is Severely Spalled or Flaking

Surface degradation (called “spalling”) happens when the top layer of concrete breaks apart.

Common causes include:

  • freeze-thaw cycles
  • heavy wear
  • poor finishing
  • salt or chemical damage
  • old age

If the issue is widespread, resurfacing won’t last — replacement is the stronger option.

4. When Water Pools or Drains Incorrectly

Poor drainage around concrete can cause major problems.

Pooling water leads to:

  • faster deterioration
  • slippery surfaces
  • mold or mildew
  • structural issues

If water consistently drains toward your home or forms puddles, replacing the concrete with proper grading is the right choice.

5. When Tree Roots Have Caused Major Damage

Roots can lift, crack, or completely displace slabs.

Signs root damage is beyond repair:

  • lifted sections
  • thick cracks
  • buckling concrete
  • uneven slabs
  • gaps between sections

In these cases, repairs won’t hold — replacement (with root management) is necessary.

6. When the Concrete Is More Than 20–30 Years Old

Concrete naturally weakens over time.

Older concrete often has:

  • deep cracks
  • structural fatigue
  • outdated reinforcement
  • weather deterioration

Replacing old concrete provides safer, longer-lasting results.

7. When Repairs Would Cost Almost as Much as Replacement

Sometimes repair quotes come close to replacement costs — but without the long-term value.

Replacement is usually better when:

  • repairs are extensive
  • the structural base is compromised
  • you want a fresh look
  • the concrete has widespread issues

Replacement gives you a clean, safe, long-lasting surface.

8. When You Want To Upgrade to a Better Material

Many homeowners replace concrete simply because they want something stronger or more beautiful.

Popular upgrade options include:

  • pavers
  • stone
  • stamped concrete
  • textured finishes
  • decorative borders

Upgrading adds value and improves curb appeal.

9. When You Need Better Long-Term Durability

Repairs can stretch the life of a slab, but they don’t eliminate the underlying issues.

Replacement offers:

  • new reinforcement
  • improved base preparation
  • better drainage
  • higher-quality materials
  • modern construction standards

It’s the best option for long-term performance.

10. When Safety Becomes a Concern

Cracked or uneven concrete can create serious safety hazards.

Issues include:

  • tripping risks
  • unstable footing
  • slippery surfaces
  • shifting slabs

Replacement eliminates these risks and restores peace of mind.

11. When You Want To Improve Curb Appeal

Damaged or outdated concrete can make your entire property look neglected.

Replacing concrete improves:

  • value
  • aesthetics
  • overall property appearance
  • functionality

A clean, updated surface instantly elevates any outdoor space.

12. When You’re Planning Other Outdoor Improvements

If you're building:

  • a patio
  • an outdoor kitchen
  • a pergola
  • a walkway
  • landscaping upgrades

…it’s often smart to replace damaged concrete at the same time. This creates a cohesive design and avoids future problems.

Repair vs. Replace: A Simple Way To Decide

Here’s a quick guide:

Repair when:

  • cracks are small
  • damage is isolated
  • drainage is good
  • the surface is mostly intact

Replace when:

  • cracks are deep or spreading
  • the slab is uneven
  • water pools
  • concrete is old
  • repairs have failed before
  • the structural base is compromised

When in doubt, a professional evaluation helps you make the right choice.

Ready To Upgrade Your Old or Damaged Concrete?

Tell us what issues you’re seeing, and we’ll recommend the best path for a strong, long-lasting solution.